Theatre Review


Defiance


Venue:
QStation, Manly (NSW)
Dates: Throughout 2008

Send us your feedback
on this review

 

 

Advertise with us |
About us
|
Our privacy policy

 


Immersive experience

Defiance tells the stories of some of the detainees of the Quarantine Station at Manly, which operated from 1828 until 1984. During that period people were quarantined during the outbreak of worldwide epidemics of diseases including Small Pox, Bubonic Plague and Spanish Influenza. Diseases which killed hundreds of millions of people. Defiance is the story of people who defied the odds of their incarceration and survived, of others who died and ordinary people who volunteered to tend the sick. There are heroes, cowards, innocent victims and at least one downright blaggard. The human spirit shines throughout in the battle against mankind’s oldest foes – disease.

Part of the uniqueness of this production is that it is playing in the very place where its characters had these experiences. Some of them are still buried on site in the graveyard. Act One takes place in the old laundry building. All the machinery you’d expect to find in a laundry is still there, it just doesn’t work any more. Like all buildings at Q Station, is State Heritage listed, which is one step below World Heritage. The machinery cannot be brought back to life, except with sound effects.

Act One concentrates on the story of the Wilson family, forcibly removed to quarantine from their Rocks home in 1881 during the Small Pox epidemic. It came out at the Royal Commission into the treatment of detainees during that time that the entire family – John and Sarah Wilson and their six children – were wrongly detained. As a result their youngest child died of Small Pox. John Wilson was quarantined on the hospital hulk, the Faraway, in the bay off Q Station. As the only person on board it became his responsibility to tend to the sick, sow the dead into their shrouds and place them in coffins for transport to shore. More than once John Wilson jumped ship in order to see his sick child, but was met with armed resistance, was caught and returned to the Faraway.

Act Two takes place in the rebuilt hospital building. The original hospital burnt down nearly five years ago, the victim of arson. The new building is built in its image. Act Two is a combination of stories about the Plague, Spanish Influenza and a glimpse into a possible future where Avian Flu runs rampant. Schwerdt plays professional rat catcher Ned Cratchely, the self-proclaimed Pied Piper of The Rocks during the 1901 outbreak of plague. Schwerdt injects Cratchely with a wry sense of humour. He becomes the narrative thread between the Plague and Spanish Influenza stories.

It’s 1918 and World War I has come to its bloody end. Nurse Kelly tends to her patients, 11 year old Clarissa and Lieutenant Gilbert. Gilbert is one of 2500 returned soldiers who went straight into quarantine for Spanish Influenza. Confined for nearly three months, Clarissa has made an imaginary friend of Cleopatra the eagle which she sketches lovingly. As it becomes certain Nurse Kelly won’t recover, Lieutenant Gilbert goes in search of a priest to give her last rites. He returns with a Bishop, but is refused entry by the guards. Nurse Kelly is buried in the graveyard on-site.

The actors play multiple roles and each character seems to fit them like a glove, they move so seamlessly from role to role. A number of accents are employed, all to great effect. Suzy is a strong presence as Sarah Wilson and Damien shines as John Wilson. Rebekah is entirely believable as the young Clarissa. She also injects some playful humour into the part of the Royal Commissioner in Act One. Schwerdt is effortlessly charming and funny as rat catcher Ned Cratchely.

But there are also some other stars of this production, namely the special effects and sound effects of Allan Hirons and Jeremy Silver, which give so much depth to the whole experience. The ring-a-ring-a-rosy visual which starts out as a flower and unfurls into a circle of skipping children is particularly powerful, as is the silhouette of Cleopatra the eagle who swoops around the walls of the hospital in Act Two. Peter Ashman’s set design using the heritage spaces is truly innovative. In particular, the prow of the Faraway in the laundry is very evocative. Throughout it all is the powerful voice of Anthony Phelan, whose narrative weaves the stories together.

The ambience at Q Station is undeniable, from the atmospheric walk between the two venues during intermission, to the spectacular views of the city skyline at night from the hospital grounds. But Defiance is more than a tourist attraction. It is an opportunity to bear witness to these incredible people’s stories and delve into a little known slice of Sydney’s history.

Authenticity is key in this production. The beds in the hospital scene are exact replicas of those used in the 1800’s. The seats are upholstered in clothing, and the laundry sound effects are exact reproductions of how the machinery used to sound. Authenticity is at the core of Q Station, which aims to provide a way to experience history in the space where it occurred. Q Station’s General Manager, Simon McCarthur, calls it immersion theatre. As he puts it “We wanted an authentic experience based on real stories about real people, caught in the wrong place at the wrong time.” McCarthur’s philosophy of “making history relevant to the present, for people to contemplate the future” is what Defiance and Q Station in its present incarnation are all about.

Defiance certainly achieves all this and much, much more.

Philippa Wherrett

 

Advertisement